As a small artist and content creator, I’m often caught in the debate of what role to take in moments like this. Should I respond directly to the violence — join the outcry, have a voice? Do I stop posting for now, in solidarity? Or do I continue to create and share my art as normal, perhaps providing a small space of refuge for folks who inevitably need a brief escape from the weight of it all?
During tragedy, there’s a clash between the obligation to stand up and fight back or to prioritize mental health. And as with most things, I think some balance of the two is key, albeit difficult to find.
I used to be a journalist, and to be very vulnerable, one of the reasons I left my professional writing career was the need to always have an angle or response to the current moment. I craved the ability to retreat into a private life, and while still staying mostly informed, to escape the official requirement to know all the latest details and act on them each day. I have so much respect for those who have stayed in journalism or communications, but for me, it was just too much.
Now, as someone who lives a mostly quiet life and creates content as just a hobby, I still struggle with the question of how artists should respond when society falls apart.
I feel that I’m holding my breath, throwing up shields, and seeking self protection. In a time when the U.S. federal government is murdering innocent citizens in the streets or dragging them from their homes without a warrant, I think it’s valid to be afraid. Not just of the potential backlash from speaking out politically, but of the real physical threat that our government has become.
I don’t live in Minneapolis, Chicago, or in any of the places where residents are seeing and feeling this violence up close. But I know these dystopian scenes could quickly spread across the country — and my suburban Indiana street looks awfully like the places where federal agents already terrorize without consequence.
So, should we keep quiet and stay safe, or should we keep creating? Should we remove ourselves to make space for those doing the more direct work of keeping our communities informed, or do we continue to provide a moment of peace and light for them and for others just trying to get through the day?
No, I don’t have an answer. Each person should respond in the way that is most right for them, and I’m still figuring out what that means for me. No one should be shamed for prioritizing their own safety and peace, or for simply living a life that does no harm. Still, I think the value of all art — whether it’s a cute animal drawing or an overt political protest — is just as important now as it always has been: To provide an outlet for both joy and rage, a reflection of humanity. To give our minds a moment to wander, in the midst of a painful world. And to inspire others to express their own experience in a way that is beautiful and free.